Which one is better?
For the vast majority of WordPress users, Matomo Analytics (Matomo for WordPress) is the better choice.
-
Why? It is an all-in-one, self-contained solution. It installs the tracking script automatically, hosts the database locally, and handles everything right inside your WordPress dashboard without requiring an external cloud subscription or a separate server.
-
When to use Connect Matomo instead: Only use Connect Matomo if you intentionally want your data sent to an external Matomo Cloud account or a completely separate server because you are managing analytics across multiple different non-WordPress platforms centrally.
Why your data stopped generating
Having both plugins active simultaneously is precisely why your tracking broke.
Because both plugins try to manage tracking and database operations at the same time, they conflict with each other. This overlap often results in broken tracking scripts, database query blocks, or complete freezes in data collection.
How to fix it:
-
Keep only one plugin: Decide which setup you want. If you want everything self-contained on WordPress, keep Matomo Analytics. If you use an external Matomo Cloud account, keep Connect Matomo.
-
Deactivate and delete the extra plugin: Go to your WordPress Plugins page and permanently deactivate and delete the one you aren’t using.
-
Clear your caches: If you use a caching plugin (like WP Rocket, LiteSpeed, or W3 Total Cache) or server-side caching, clear your cache so old broken scripts stop serving to visitors.
-
Verify tracking: Open your website in an Incognito/private browsing window, click around a few pages, wait about 1–2 minutes, and check your Matomo real-time reports to confirm data is flowing again.